AfterBites: Expanding Consumer Protection Laws to Software
by Marcus J. Ranum on May 13, 2009
The Story:
Source: http://news.cnet.com/8301-1001_3-10237212-92.htmlEU Commissioners Call For Expanding Consumer Protection Laws to Software
(May 9, 2009) - European Union Commissioners Viviane Reding and Meglena Kuneva have proposed that the EU Sales and Guarantee Directive, which applies tophysical products, be extended "to cover licensing agreements of products like software" as well. The directive requires that products carry a two-year guarantee. Kuneva said that the change would give customers a broader choice and software companies would be held to a higher standard of accountability. Business Software Alliance Senior Director of Public Policy in Europe Francisco Mingorance disagreed, saying that it would in fact limit consumers' choices. He said that "creators of digital goods cannot predict with a high degree of certainty both the product's anticipated uses and its potentialperformance," and that it could lead to decreased interoperability between products if manufacturers decide to limit how much of their code could be accessible to third-party developers.
This has been tried before and - it should come as no surprise to anyone - the software industry has some mighty powerful lobbyists. Indeed, some of them speak out in this little tidbit. I think it would have been more honest if Business Software Alliance Senior Director of Public Policy in Europe Francisco Mingorance had said "Good luck, bwaaaahaaahaaahaaaa!" instead of hewing the ridiculous party line that the software industry has been spouting for decades. I like intellectual honesty when I encounter it.